Assignment 19A- Idea Napkin No. 2
Still Pretend this is a Napkin
1) You. Who you are.
What your talents are. What your skills and experiences are. Also: what are
your aspirations? Specifically, regarding your business concept, how do you see
this business (if you were to start it) playing a role in your life?
- My name is Madylin McConnell and I am a first-year
student and I am a Business Administration General Studies major with an
intended major in Urban Planning. I intend to get a minor in Real Estate
and apply for the Masters of International Business Program. I am in the
UF Honors Program and am also a first-generation student. After talking to
five people closest to me and reflecting on interviews, I am someone who
possesses good communication skills. I have been able to complete all of
the assignments and effectively communicate with many different sources to
gather the information I currently possess. I have experience in
leadership and planning events with teams. I have held different
leadership positions such as being the Class of 2019 Class Representative
for the International Baccalaureate Program Student Union in high school.
I had the opportunity to plan a cultural festival that entailed four
months of planning and improving my team working skills. I aspire to
continue to learn and grow as a person. I want to live out a career that I
am good at, but also one that I get satisfaction from doing. If I were to
start this business, I would not want it to be my main career. I would
want to develop and launch the product, with ambitions of selling it for
profit after a few years.
2) What are you offering to customers? Describe the product or
service (in other words, how you'll solve customers' unmet needs).
- This part has not changed and I do not plan on it
changing for the rest of the semester. I am offering both scooter owners
and scooter dealers a way to protect merchandise and property from being
stolen. For individuals, I am solving their problem because the locks
currently on the market are obviously not effective and do not include a
method for property recovery. Scooter dealers can increase their sales by
having a very effective method of ensuring customers that their investment
will not get stolen after a few days or months. From my interviews, I
learned that some college students haven’t invested in scooters because
they have heard of so many people getting stolen. Companies that sell
these locks can use it as a way to promote the sale of their
scooters.
3) Who are you offering it to? Describe, in as much detail as
possible, the demographic and psychographic characteristics of your customers.
Think especially of this question: what do your customers all have in common?
- My
market is narrowly defined as scooter owners and scooters. Individuals
include scooters, moped, and potentially motorcycle owners. Individuals
who own scooters in concentrated places like college towns where scooter
usage is high and ranges only for a few miles of transportation are especially
in the market. Individuals who live in European cities, such as London are
very likely to need better anti-theft locks due to high theft rates. I
could make lower and higher-priced ranges for different income levels. I
don’t think the difference would have to be that large, because most
individuals would be willing to protect there over a thousand dollar
property.
- For businesses, the main
companies I would offer the product to would-be scooter and auto sales
companies. The first dealers that would be contacted would be ones in
college towns and cities that use mopeds as one of their primary means of
transportation.
- Based on feedback from my last
idea napkin, places of high tourism could also be a potential customer.
Hotels or companies that rent out scooters to tourists would be interested
in protecting their products from theft. This is a market that I had
previously not recognized.
- Amazon
is also a universal market that I could reach potential customers.
4) Why do they care? Your solution is only valuable insofar as
customers believe it’s valuable to them. Here, explain why customers will
actually pay you money to use your product or service.
- This has not changed. From interviews, I have confirmed
that scooter owners would rather buy a lock than a whole other scooter.
Also, I have learned that potential buyers would be more inclined to
purchase a scooter if I believe that scooter owners and scooter dealers
will buy my product because it is beneficial for both of them. From the
consumers perspective, it is much cheaper to buy a 50 to 100 dollar
anti-theft lock, rather than investing in another thousand dollars plus
scooter. While businesses may make more profit by selling an entire new
scoter, they may make more sales if they have the locks initially. From
the business’s perspective, they could use the fact that customers will be
more assured that their property will not get stolen in order to sell more
scooters. In both cases, both parties save money or make more money from
the purchase of antitheft locks.
5) What are your core competencies? What sets you apart from
everyone else? Also: what do you have that nobody else has?
- This remains the same because I have yet to find a
similar lock on the market. As far as my knowledge goes, no other
antitheft locks have attempted to combine three different types of locks.
I have also not been able to find systems that come with tracking systems,
in order to recover your property, just in case it does get stolen. I am
not saying that this product would 100% prevent theft, however, it would
greatly decrease any odds and help reclaim the property if it does get
stolen. The first step is prevention, but recovery also needs to be
considered.
In addition to these five elements, please spend a paragraph
evaluating whether you believe these elements fit together or whether there are
aspects of your business concept that are weaker / out-of-joint with the
others.
- I think that my elements work well together, however, I
have two areas of concern. First, I think that the market of businesses
may be smaller than the market for individuals. Businesses could think in
the opposite way, “Why would I want to prevent scooters from being stolen
when it means they might buy another one?” I would have to research into
the perspective that scooter sellers would take before preceding. Finally,
I do not have any current connections that would help me launch this
product or5 have money for research in development. This would be a hurdle
that I would have to overcome before proceeding.
Feedback Memo:
- One
of my main points of feedback was that I was missing a very large part of
my market segment that I had yet to identify. This segment was
tourist-filled towns that rent our scooters and similar vehicles. These
rental companies would want to protect their rentals, so, therefore, could
potentially be a very large part of the market. I included this under the
who I am offering it to section.
- Another
point that was mentioned in the feedback was when I made the point that
businesses might not want to seel the lock because they make more revenue
when people have to buy a whole new scooter. The feedback suggested to add
that people may be more likely to by a scooter if they do have the lock,
so it really just depends on which option carries more weight. I edited
this under the why they care section.
Hi Mady,
ReplyDeleteLike you, most of my insights from the first idea napkin did not change much on my second idea napkin. However, you made a great insight in the feedback memo that a huge chunk of your market segment is people who rent scooters in tourist-towns. I didn't even think about this, but I'm sure this could be a great opportunity to sell more scooter locks to scooter companies. And as far as the other bit of feedback, I would not be too concerned about businesses not wanting to sell locks because they make more money off of people having to buy new scooters. Especially after watching the lecture with NS4L, I personally think that a scooter business would want to help the customer by doing everything they can to protect them and take care of their scooters. Yes, they want to make money, but not at the expense of their loyal customers. Just my thought, anyway!
Like I said to another student in this class, I think that the self-worth assignment really helped us to become more confident discussing our strengths. I think those that invest in your idea would understand that this is not a full proof plan but they might be more cautious with their property by even purchasing this safety lock. Also, what about a system that makes noises much like a car alarm? It might deter thieves.
ReplyDeleteHi Mady. I still think this is a really good idea, especially marketed to college students who drive scooters, but also as a mass marketed product for all scooter/motorcycle owners. I do agree that you would probably have the most success selling to individuals, and selling on Amazon would help you reach a worldwide network of buyers. I think you did a good job of incorporating the feedback from your first idea napkin into this assignment, and I like that you amended your "who you are" section to include the feedback from another assignment. Great work!
ReplyDeleteHi Mady!
ReplyDeleteVery insightful post! By expanding your market segment, you can effectively sell your lock and tracker system to not only college students and dealers, but also to tourists that rent scooters. This could be a big market for you to exploit, as people who are visiting a school are more inclined to rent a scooter temporarily rather than buy one out right. In addition, I like how you mentioned why this product would be great for both scooter companies and buyers. You would think that if a scooter gets stolen, it would mean better business for the company because the individual would have to buy another one. However, there is no guarantee that the individual would buy another scooter without adequate protection, like your lock and tracker system.
Madi, this is actually the first time I have been on your blog, and I must say, GREAT JOB! Your design is very clean and appealing. I like how you have a very narrow market. One of the things I have struggled with is really narrowing down my market so that I know who to target with what resources. You seem to have this figured out pretty well, so good on you!
ReplyDelete